Resort vs Rented apartment: Battle of the Pools  (Brian Thacker)
Blog Words : Family Travel | 13 April

Which is best: resort or rented villa?

Travel author Brian Thacker took his young family to Bali, dividing time between a resort villa and one rented privately. Which one came out on top?

On a recent family trip to Bali, travel author Brian Thacker, shared his time between a villa in a resort in Nusa Lemobongan and a private villa in Ubud booked through Airbnb. So which is better for a family trip: a resort or rental?

Booking the accommodation

Resort villa

I booked our resort in Nusa Lembongan only two hours before we arrived, after discovering the resort we'd originally booked had burnt down the day before. Luckily, it was the off season and we had plenty of options to choose from. I simply went to my Trip Advisor App on my phone and found a 2-bedroom villa in a resort, then went to the Trivago App and found the cheapest deal and then to Bookings.com to make the actual booking. All up, it took about nine minutes.

Private villa

I booked our villa in Ubud through Airbnb when I booked our airfare 8 months earlier. If I had tried to book it two months before we left, the villa would have more than likely been booked already.

Arrival

Resort villa

A staff member from the resort was waiting for us on the beach – we arrived by boat – and he carried our bags up five flights of stairs to reception. We got the usual fruity-flowery welcome drink and cold face-towel, but our room wasn’t ready. (We arrived at 11.00 and had to wait until 2.00). We could use the pool, though, so we went for a swim and had lunch by the pool.

Once we were shown to our room a staff member went through the usual ‘Here is the light switch’, etc.

Private villa

Our host’s son met us at the top of the steps down to the villa and carried our bags down. Although it was 11.30 and ‘check-in’ wasn’t until 2.00 we could move straight in. We were shown all the light switches and handed a PDF print out of the latest Lonely Planet guide to Ubud.

Pool at private resort, Ubud (Brian Thacker)Private villa, Ubud

The accommodation

Resort villa

Our villa, which was up a thigh-burning 150 steps or so from reception, had two bedrooms, both with ensuites, a large lounge area, kitchen and large balcony. At the end of the balcony was a small pool-table-sized plunge pool. It was a short but gut-busting walk down the stairs to the beach and restaurants and breakfast each morning!

Private villa

Our villa, which was surrounded by jungle, was set in a private walled garden. The villa had two bedrooms with only one bathroom, a small lounge area, kitchen and a large paved garden with a full-sized swimming pool. The villa was a ten-minute walk to Monkey Forest Road (the main dining and shopping street).

Facilities and staff

Resort villa

It was a resort, so it had all the resorty-type facilities, including breakfast, a swimming pool, in-room free Wi-Fi, daily sheet and towel change service and lots of friendly staff.

The front desk staff were great and very helpful. I booked a snorkelling trip, scooter hire and a restaurant on the other side of the island. We requested a cot for our young son and it was free and in the room when we arrived.

Private villa

The big thing was the big pool. On Airbnb you can use filters to fine tune your search, including price, location, how many rooms and, in our case, it had to have a private pool.

Our villa was cleaned daily by our host, but the sheets and towels weren’t changed. Our pool was cleaned every second day as well. We also had Wi-Fi. We requested a cot and our host organised one to be delivered from Denpasar – which was in the room when we arrived. The hiring fee was $10 a day.

Food

Resort villa

Breakfast was included, with a choice of continental breakfast, omelette or banana pancakes. We had breakfast by the pool and, most mornings, we were the only guests there.

The resort also had a simple lunch and dinner menu, but other restaurants were so close we only ate one lunch there. We had a full kitchen, but we didn’t really use it at all because eating out was so cheap.

Private villa

We’d bought breakfast cereal and peanut butter with us from Australia, so only needed to get milk and bread from a local convenience store. We also ate out for breakfast once – because it was so cheap. There were lots of restaurants within walking distance from the villa. There was actually a lot of amazing (and cheaper!) villas outside of Ubud, but they were a taxi trip away from restaurants.

Resort pool in Bali (Brian Thacker)Resort pool in  Nusa Lembong, Bali

Privacy

Resort villa

I hate masses of crowds around a pool and breakfast buffet, but that is not so much of problem in a smaller resort. OK, there wasn't a Kid’s Club or room service, but we were  happy to skip that for a little bit of peace and quiet.

We were also lucky that it was off-season, so we pretty much had the pool to ourselves most days. The only downside was on our last night when a large group of Japanese tourists moved in next door and had a loud party until the wee hours.

Private villa

Our villa was a private little oasis. We couldn’t see or hear anybody and, being surrounded by jungle, we really felt as if we were in the wilderness – even though we were pretty much right in town.

Pros and cons

Pro private villa

You can save a whole heap of money. Not only that, you can often get a lot more room for your cash, making it particularly cost effective for families. Our private villa was half the price of the resort.

Con private villa

You do really need to book early. The earlier the better. You may find the perfect place, but it may be booked when you want stay. This is particularly likely if you’re going to a popular destination and the property has lots of great reviews. To get a place you like you need to book far, far ahead.

Pro resort villa

Staff – when you need them. It’s nice to have a receptionist to book tours and restaurants. I also do like getting clean sheets and towels. And admittedly, I am on holidays, so I like having breakfast included instead of eating soggy cereal.

Con resort villa

Screaming kids and screaming drunks. There’s not much privacy. It was okay where we stayed (besides the drunk Japanese), but I’ve stayed in many a resort surrounded by the hordes day and night.

Brian Thacker is an award-winning travel writer with seven books under his belt. To find out more about Brian and his books, drop by his website, brianthacker.tv.

>